jscratch wrote:I agree with you on one point, that powerlifting is not about health and fitness. It's a sport, where competitors lift heavy fucking weights. The very best aren't training to be healthy. They're training to be elite at lifting heavy weight. That's the nature of sport. It's not about health and I'm not seeing why you think it's being suggested it is.
I disdain crossfit because not only are they claiming health and fitness (which they don't deliver), but they're also claiming elite status (which again they don't deliver, obviously).
If I were to suggest a program for health and fitness, I would much rather go with powerlifting influenced training (not maxing all the time, but real weights with quality exercises done with good volume) and regular cardio and stretching.
As a strength sport, Powerlifting >>> CrossFit
As a fitness system, Powerlifting == Crossfit
To me, powerlifting is a sport, while CrossFit is not. If I judge CrossFit as a sport, then it fails compared to powerlifting. Likewise, if I judge powerlifting as a health and fitness system then it fails as well.
All I'm saying is that both CrossFit and powerlifting are low on the list when it comes to functional, every day health and fitness.